what the bleep do we know debunked

I'm always up for a good New Age flick, even one masquerading as a documentary. We hear more and more from JZ Knight, a woman channeling the ancient warrior Ramtha, a chap who (through Knight) incidentally leads the Ramtha School of Enlightenment. [4] The visual-effects team, led by Evan Jacobs, worked closely with the other film-makers to create visual metaphors that would capture the essence of the film's technical subjects with attention to aesthetic detail. In addition to the films three directors, there were actors and others involved in the production who are long time students of Ramthas School of enlightenment. Joe Dispenza 1. His 73 papers are mostly about supersymmetric GUTs and considered quite respectable, with a total of over 5000 citations, including 641 citations for one of them alone. He also has been marketing several products within the school and its followers. I had it recommended to me by no less than three people. Get ABC Sciences weekly newsletter Science Updates, The 'underground astronaut' in search of ancient bones, Voyager probes still signalling from the edge of the Solar System, Solar eclipses: Everything you need to know, Five ways your smartphone could help save lives, Chinese scientists use satellite to smash quantum entanglement record, Einstein's light bending theory directly observed in distant stars for first time, Third gravitational wave detection puts new spin on black holes. It was amusing when John Hagelin tried to run for US president representing the Natural Law party during the 1990s. Interspersed with the plot were interviews with various supposed scientists with something to say about quantum physics, consciousness, God, etc. A: Absolutely. When you hear the term "quantum consciousness," you should be suspicious. (I haven't). Doesn't the quantum world pervade everything that we see around us? based on this subject nature contained, I hold these 2 films in a very high regard. As the sample size grows, so does the scientist's confidence in the statistical inferences drawn from the large sample. Adapted from "Ask the Everyday Scientist" with permission of the writer. But when the ramblings about quantum physics start merging with fridge magnet philosophy, it's time for a little reality checking. !" is a radical departure from convention. This will be revisited if any. Q: Obviously, quantum mechanics has lots of real-life applications, including in your television set and your microwave oven. Hope you dont mind me butting in, just thought you might like to see these facts which are so far undisputed about the film. The 2004 theatrical release was succeeded by a substantially changed, extended home media version in 2006. Where were we now? One of the scientists interviewed is John Hagelin who, besides being part of the TM cult surrounding Maharishi Mahesh Yogi, presidential candidate of the Natural Law Party, and Minister of Science and Technology of the Global Country of World Peace is a rather prominent particle theorist. The pity of it is that there are fascinating conversations going on in the science-and-religion sphere. [5] Author Barrie Dolnick adds that "people don't want to learn how to do one thing. To accomplish that, you would have to invoke "new physics," Dr. Schumm says, in which the explanation can be verified or falsified through experiment. Hambling says it is likely that both the Hughes account and the story told by Pert were exaggerations of the records left by Captain Cook and the botanist Joseph Banks. But most of the talking heads' quotes seem either to have a hidden agenda, or to be sliced and diced to buttress Ramtha's ideas. Real news, real hope. Consciousness must be involved. That beliefs about who one is and what is real are a direct cause of oneself and of one's own realities. The idea that our own perceptions can't be trusted is not new, of course. In the late eighties I remember seeing Maharishi University preprints, perhaps about flipped SU(5). My FIL is a ex-Air force Pilot. is a book of amazing science, and now the international bestselling book is available in paperback. The web makes all such things available today, so I can give you a Google link to a page about Maharishis unified field theory, http://www.worldpeaceendowment.org/invincibility/invincibility6.html. Thus, if a scientist repeats an experiment with subatomic particles often enough, the results will closely match the probabilities quantum theory predicts. The film was also discussed in a letter published in Physics Today that challenges how physics is taught, saying teaching fails to "expose the mysteries physics has encountered [and] reveal the limits of our understanding". Our mind has enormous potential, but we only use a small part of it for conscious thought, and we miss a lot of what's going on around us. 2. It was an interesting idea aiming to solve the hierachy problem, as announced. Directors William Arntz, Betsy Chasse Starring Marlee Matlin, Elaine Hendrix, John Ross Bowie Genres Science Fiction, Comedy, Drama, Documentary, Fantasy, Special Interest You should be wary whenever you hear something like, "Quantum mechanics connects you with the universe" or "quantum mechanics unifies you with everything else." Now I don't have an automatic prejudice against 35,000-year-old warriors from Atlantis or the women who channel them. You see my physics students don't understand it. That is because I don't understand it. It's actually the machine that's the observer, not the human who's jotting down results. I guess the difference between me and those other people is that I actually have some grasp on the concepts that the movie was trying to talk about. Hagelin might be crazy, but some of those papers are co-written by John Ellis and other respectable people. Pingback: Not Even Wrong Blog Archive Hidden Dimensions, Pingback: Rachels Musings Rabbit Holes and Other Oddities, Pingback: Not Even Wrong Blog Archive Philosophy of Science on Blogginheads.tv, Pingback: For "The Baby Goes Out With The Bathwater" Crowd - SLUniverse Forums. DO WE KNOW? [12][13] Lisa Randall refers to the film as "the bane of scientists". IE 11 is not supported. The observer effect of quantum physics isn't about people or reality. is god-awful. have described distinct assertions made as pseudoscience. Q: But isn't everything really connected? Human everyday life consists of many routines and necessary things that are mostly physical such as work, school, a number of chores or minor responsibilities, and hopefully sleep. Last night I went to see a movie which was advertised as being about quantum physics, called What the Bleep Do We Know?. Z. Knight and heavily features commentary from 'Ramtha', an ancient Atlantian general who is apparently speaking through Knight. There's nothing wrong with that. ISHEAGU MASSACRE HISTORICAL BACKGROUND: Isheagu is a town whose origin is traceable to the Eastern part of the contraption called Nigeria. Quantum physics tells us that reality isn't fixed subatomic particles only come into existence when they are observed and 2. According to his books, water exposed to loving words shows brilliant and attractive patterns, while water exposed to negative thoughts forms incomplete patterns. Miceal Ledwith When a movie gets rave reviews as a mind-blowing flick about quantum physics, it's worth checking out. Mark was born in Johannesburg, South Africa . That's why we experience a classical world. But sounding like magic and being magic are two different things. improve functionality and performance. But no scientific discovery has proved so ripe for spiritual projection as the theories of quantum physics, replete with their quixotic qualities of uncertainty, simultaneity and parallelism." Cathleen Falsani, who must have been taking notes while I was staring gobsmacked at the screen, quotes the 35,year-old . With Marlee Matlin, Elaine Hendrix, Barry Newman, Armin Shimerman. Staff meetings are tedious enough give me a conscious mind with a decent filter device any day. Well, people are able to undergo various transformations. About. Both are indeed mysterious, and their genuine mystery needs none of the hype with which this film relentlessly and noisily belabours us", concluding that the film is "tosh". (Physicists should take part of the blame for this confusion. And quantum mechanics is often used as the explanation for that. What the Bleep Do We Know was directed and produced by Betsy Chasse, Mark Vicente and William Arntz, all of whom were students of Ramthas School of Enlightenment. Hidden Messages In Water Hidden Messages in . There are also phrases plagiarized entire from "The Matrix," a far superior film treatment of the notion that reality isn't what it seems. What the Bleep Do We Know!? Blending New Age mysticism and quantum physics, What The Bleep Do We Know?! On August 1, 2006 What the Bleep! With quantum mechanics, there's a notion that observers affect the things that they're observing. you refer to the offspring of hep-ph/9803315. And if you really want to be friendly, ask me about "The Case forPluto.". This has led to accusations, both formal and informal, directed towards the film's proponents, of spamming online message boards and forums with many thinly veiled promotional posts. Presentations ranging from "The Secret" to "What the Bleep Do We Know?" But are there new, weird applications that people might see that have an impact on everyday life, beyond the woo-woo? Featuring interviews with scientists and theologians, this compelling film thrusts the viewer into a world where science and spirituality intersect. Occasionally recalling a physics lesson, an acid trip, and a lost afternoon at a New Age bookstore, What The BLEEP Do We Know?! Hambling says it is likely that both the Hughes account and the story told by Pert were exaggerations of the records left by Captain Cook and the botanist Joseph Banks. Not exactly, Amit. Not Even Wrong Blog Archive Hidden Dimensions, Rachels Musings Rabbit Holes and Other Oddities, Not Even Wrong Blog Archive Philosophy of Science on Blogginheads.tv, For "The Baby Goes Out With The Bathwater" Crowd - SLUniverse Forums. A movie and a book said that water molecules are. We must shake off the "ugly, superstitious, backwater concept of God" we learned as children, chides JZ Knight--uh, Ramtha. Fred Allen Wolf 1. But quantum-mechanical computers might be able to, and then of course we'd have to start thinking about how to make things more secure. It demands a freedom of view and greatness of thought so far unknown, indeed, not even dreamed of since Copernicus. for only $16.05 $11/page. Having watched this travesty of a movie, any real scientist worth his quarks might be gun-shy about joining the debate. If quantum physics baffled the late Dr. Feynman, one of its most brilliant explorers, then no one should feel embarrassed for failing to understand the subject. ", "What the Bleep Do We Know!? A scientist debunks the claim that water reacts to human emotions. I want to mention another point Maharishi Mahesh Yogi. He even called in to a radio program the director was on to discuss this and was cut off. . The meditation may not have helped the victims of violent crime, but it did win Hagelin the 1994 Ig Nobel Peace Prize. 3. It's truly amazing that you can separate two elementary particles that were originally tied together, and often make a measurement of one particle that instantly affects the other, even if it's on Alpha Centauri. This is an explanation to help understand what might be going on, but it is not part of the theory because it is not falsifiable: it cannot be tested in such a way that, if it were false, it would fail the test (without falsifying the whole of quantum mechanics, and therefore all the other interpretations too). The experts start "proving" that humans create their own reality by getting too attached to certain brain chemicals. Quantum mechanics may play a role at some level in the way the brain works just as it may play a role in photosynthesis. Amanda is a divorced woman who makes a living as a photographer. Right now they use a key that's based on the products of large prime numbers, and no computer could determine the prime factors in a time shorter than the age of the universe. Some movies are so bad, they're funny. This will be revisited if anyone else tries to circumvent a channel ban in future.PLEASE READ CAREFULLY:I'm citing \"Fair Use\" under US Copyright Act, Title 17 512 (g)(f), specifically those clauses covering Comment and Criticism, as well as the DMCA.http://www.aclunc.org/issues/technology/blog/asset_upload_file939_6218.pdfAlso \"Fair Dealing\" under UK Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988 c.48, Part 1(Copyright) Section 79.4ahttp://www.opsi.gov.uk/acts/acts1988/ukpga_19880048_en_4Censorship is NOT a valid argument.This is the first part of my critical analysis of \"What The Bleep Do We Know?! 3) Lots of people still hunger for a magical universe, and now hope that science can deliver it, after Nietsche's announcement of God's death. The Heisenberg Uncertainty Principle argues that its impossible to track the momentum and position of a subatomic particle. If I didnt know any better, I would have thought it was something straight out of a Cheech and Chong movie. And while I dont think supersymmetric GUTs are anywhere near as promising as many people seem to think, they are a much saner idea than many that dominate research these days (take the Landscape, please). Our mind has enormous potential, but we only use a small part of it for conscious thought, and we miss a lot of what's going on around us so, in a leap of creatively edited logic 3. And I came out of wanting to meditate more often, which can't be a bad thing. It was really hard to sit through. What the Bleep Do We Know!? - - Science and engineering are important for our future, and anything that engages the public can only be a good thing." While the (probabilistic) predictions of quantum mechanics are, as far . But this only applies to sub-atomic particles a rock doesn't need you to bump into it to exist. Interspersed with the plot were interviews with various supposed scientists with something to say about quantum physics, consciousness, God, etc. His list of "worst abusers" includes inspirational author Deepak Chopra, the best-selling book "The Secret" and the whole field of Transcendental Meditation. For many years in the early-mid-eighties, the Maharishi was pushing N=8 supergravity as the unified field theory, I remember a colorful poster explaining how it agreed exactly with his philosophy that many people posted on their walls. (Refugees in Sudan or people in Baghdad would have an even tougher time accepting the film's premise.). Regular indicators of violent crime told a different story the number of murders actually went up. Viewers instead are fed a nauseating stream of nonsense that traces back to the teaching of a woman who claims to channel a 35,000-year-old deity. Also, the movie suggests that the quantum idea of matter embracing all its possible states at once applies to the larger world of people and rocks. That sounds like magic. : Directed by William Arntz, Betsy Chasse, Mark Vicente. mixed truisms with conjecture, interviews and dramatic "recreations" of the ideas being discussed, to form a kind of cohesive supposition on the link between mind and matter, biology and the Big Bang. What the Bleep!? If you have questions about your account, please The year's most unexpected indie hit in American cinemas - a film about quantum physics - is about to open here. Photos View All Photos Movie Info Amanda, a divorced photographer, has a fantastic experience when life begins to unravel around her, revealing the cellular,. There were many more, but I will leave them for others. Amanda is a photographer, who seems to be highly skilled but not very successful professionally. Neither of them convincingly achieve this. Hagelin was a grad student at Harvard when I was an undergrad and I met him when we were in the same quantum field theory class. Quantum physics tells us that reality isn't fixed subatomic particles only come into existence when they are observed and 2. presents a viewpoint of the physical universe and human life within it, with connections to neuroscience and quantum physics. Interspersed with Amanda's woes and the pseudoscience are random attacks on organized religion. To date, there has been no response as to where the information which lead to the story about the indians not being able to see the ships of Columbus originated from. The main thing to know is that "observation" is a bad word for the process which goes on which we have inherited from the days when quantum mechanics was first discovered, and is unfortunately a bit easier to teach in introductory courses than decoherence. In fact, "you are God in the making," which explains why Shirley MacLaine is a Ramtha fan. Given a few contextual clues, like whether the eyelids are open or shut, it can work out whether it's seeing something or remembering it. [14] Amongst the assertions in the film that have been challenged are that water molecules can be influenced by thought (as popularized by Masaru Emoto), that meditation can reduce violent crime rates of a city,[15] and that quantum physics implies that "consciousness is the ground of all being." Author, speaker, and award-winning Writer/Director/Producer Mark Vicente was part of the creative team behind the sleeper hit "What The Bleep Do We Know?!". The fact that someone who spouts such utter nonsense can get a Ph.D. from Harvard and be one of the most widely cited authors on supersymmetric models is pretty remarkable. One other area where quantum mechanics works on a macroscopic scale is in superconductivity and superfluidity. 1. But whenever one is dealing with highly speculative ideas that have no connection with experiment, theres a danger of becoming delusional and thinking that youre doing real science when youre not. up and at each step we're eliminating information and finally what is bubbling up to consciousness is the one that is most self-serving. But I start to choke on my $8 popcorn when science is manipulated to make a cult leader's claims sound more plausible. But when animated, jive-talkin' human cells start dancing around in what appears to be the heroine's frontal lobe, all questions of spirituality pale before the sheer dreadfulness of this movie. But that doesn't mean that astrology is true. It is true that quantum mechanics is extremely strange, and on extremely small scales for short times, all sorts of weird things happen. The film "What the Bleep Do We Know?!" [9] In his review, Dave Kehr of The New York Times described the "transition from quantum mechanics to cognitive therapy" as "plausible", but stated also that "the subsequent leapfrom cognitive therapy into large, hazy spiritual beliefsisn't as effectively executed.